‘It lets us down all over again’ says advocate on delay of advice on MMIWG inquiry’s Calls for Justice

 By Shari Narine, Local Journalism Initiative Reporter, Windspeaker.com

(Jan. 5, 2021) – Indigenous families and friends of murdered and missing women and girls will have to wait a little longer for Alberta’s MMIWG joint working group to provide direction to the Jason Kenney government on how the province should move to implement the 231 Calls for Justice in the final report of the National Inquiry into Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women and Girls.

The joint working group has asked for a “little extension” because of difficulties in gathering during the coronavirus pandemic, said Indigenous Relations Minister Rick Wilson.

“I want to have (the working group’s report) before the second anniversary coming out of when the report was released,” said Wilson.

The national inquiry’s final report was released June 3, 2019.

In March 2020, the Alberta government established a seven-member joint working group consisting of four Indigenous women and three MLAs. That group was tasked with providing “advice, direction and input into the Alberta government’s proposed action plan to address the calls for justice” from the national inquiry. The working group was given a one-year mandate.

Along with Indigenous Relations, the ministries of Justice, and Culture, Multiculturalism and Status of Women are also involved.

Wilson said he spoke with the joint working group in early December and they outlined issues they wanted to focus on and actions that could be taken immediately. However, he would not elaborate, saying “that will be their announcement to say that.”

Josie Nepinak, executive director of Awo Taan Healing Lodge Society, is one of four Indigenous women to sit on the working group. Nepinak would not offer any comment as to the delay. She directed Windspeaker.com to speak to one of the two co-chairs. However, neither Lisa Higgerty, executive director with the Hinton Friendship Centre, nor Rachelle Venne, CEO of the Institute for the Advancement of Aboriginal Women, were available for comment. The other Indigenous member on the group is Suzanne Life-Yeomans, co-chair of the First Nations Women’s Council on Economic Security.

Representing the government on the working group are MLAs Martin Long (West Yellowhead) and Whitney Issik (Calgary-Glenmore).

The third MLA, Tanya Fir (Calgary-Peigan), was stripped of her position on Jan. 4 by Premier Kenney. She was one of six MLAs to travel outside of Canada over the Christmas holiday despite government and health advice to remain in-country during the COVID pandemic.

Joseph Dow, spokesperson for Indigenous Relations, said a decision had not yet been made as to who would replace Fir.

It is unclear whether Fir’s dismissal will further delay the report.

Any delay does not sit well with Stephanie Harpe, an advocate for Indigenous families.

“It lets us down all over again. It makes us feel continuously failed. It makes us feel we’re not important and that non-action speaks louder than anything to all of us,” said Harpe.

Harpe’s mother Ruby Anne McDonald was murdered in 1999 in Edmonton. The Edmonton Police Service (EPS) has yet to charge anyone in her death.

Harpe shared her story and her experience with EPS when the national inquiry for MMIWG was in Edmonton in November 2017.

“I got to tell my truth. Powerful. Great. Okay, that’s fine. And I got to help a lot of Canadians start to understand. That’s wonderful,” she said.

“Then there was the cry of genocide, but where was our uprising? Where was our march? Where was our gathering? Where was the urgency? Everyone played with that name. Everyone ignored that word. And that is the truth. So that was a major let down,” she said.

The report from the national inquiry said the deaths of Indigenous women and girls in Canada constituted a genocide.

“Not having Canadians understand the true genocide of what’s happening here. This isn’t historical… People are thinking this happened so long ago, (saying) we’re so sorry. No. it’s still happening,” said Harpe.

She expressed concern that the joint working group may not understand the urgency of the need for action because three of the members are not Indigenous.

“There are many Indigenous people that are very over-educated, that are very, very educated in this who are able to take those jobs, to relate, who can understand, who live it,” said Harpe. “To have non-Indigenous people in those roles that affect us, that hold that power for change, that hold that information back from us, that don’t move forward on the action.”

Harpe also calls into question that Indigenous people are not in control of what happens to them.

“All these people that are in these hierarchies that control our fate, we are not at that table of decision-making power yet and it’s wrong. That’s the whole reason why it’s not working for us,” she said.

To illustrate her point, she notes that last year when the national inquiry’s report hit its first anniversary it wasn’t marked by the Alberta government. It was Harpe, along with Stolen Sisters and Brothers founder April Eve Wiberg, who organized a convoy which traveled from Borden Park in Edmonton to the Alberta Legislature on June 3, 2020.

“That was powerful. The whole parking lot was full. We never saw that kind of gathering before. That was the only way we could get the attention,” said Harpe.

Action is what Harpe is after and she says that sentiment is shared by the many, many Indigenous families who tell her their stories.

“I hear from all of our people. That’s something I take very sacred. I’m honoured to do it. I just need the proper changes of action to happen now. Now 2021 is all about action. We’re done talking,” said Harpe.

Wilson insists the government has not been sitting still when it comes to measures to protect women.

The Disclosure to Protect Against Domestic Violence (commonly known as Clare’s Law) passed in October 2019. It allows access to a partner’s personal information if an individual feels at risk of domestic violence. Also, Bill 28, the Vital Statistics Amendment Act, which came into effect in July 2020, prevents anyone 18 or over who has been convicted of a “designated sexual offence” from legally changing their name.

Wilson also pushed in 2019 for Oct. 4 to be officially declared as Sisters in Spirit day in Alberta. The day honours missing and murdered Indigenous women and girls.

Shari Narine is a  Local Journalism Initiative Reporter for Windspeaker.com.

1 Comment on "‘It lets us down all over again’ says advocate on delay of advice on MMIWG inquiry’s Calls for Justice"

  1. Rachelle Venne | January 16, 2021 at 5:39 pm | Reply

    Email: [email protected]

    The Alberta Joint Working Group on Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women and Girls would like the opportunity to respond to the article that was in the online Windspeaker on January 5th, 2021. We would first like to clarify that the reporter of the article did reach out by email to one of the Co-Chairs, Lisa Higgerty, at 9:01 AM. At 2:37 pm the article was published. They did not give a timeline nor a reasonable opportunity to respond. The other Co-Chair was not contacted at all.
    The Working Group is made up of Indigenous and non-Indigenous members committed to listening and preparing recommendations for the provincial government on the 231 Calls for Justice. The Working Group was created on March 5, 2020, less than two weeks after the provincial government declared a public health emergency due to COVID-19.
    The subject matter is difficult, and we want to honor the families affected by the MMIWG in a respectful manner. Our group has identified priorities and established a work plan to examine them. Once the priorities have been examined, we will draft recommendations. Our timeline has been extended to December 31, 2021, due to difficulties in meeting as a result of COVID-19.
    The Working Group has a quarterly newsletter; the winter 2020 edition will be coming out shortly and will provide more information on the work we are doing. We strive to be transparent, inclusive and informative. As co-chairs, we happy to have conversations with the Windspeaker at any time.

    Lisa Higgerty​​​​​​
    Rachelle Venne

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published.